Skip to content

Renters Insurance in Carthage, TX

Renters insurance covers your belongings inside a rented unit and provides liability protection if a guest is injured. Many Texas landlords require it. Average annual cost is well under $200, making it one of the highest-value insurance products available.

9 renters insurance agencies in Carthage

Within 15 miles of Carthage, TX. Click any agency to view profile, contact info, and request a quote.

LFeatured partner
LIBERTAS INSURANCEPaid placement

Libertas Insurance (Libertas Group, LLC) is an independent insurance agency headquartered in Waco, Texas, with a second office in Austin, serving individuals, families, and businesses across the state. As an independent agency, Libertas isn't tied to a single carrier — it compares multiple companies to fit each client's needs across personal lines (auto, home, life, umbrella, flood, boat, and motorcycle) and a full range of commercial coverage, including general liability, commercial property, workers' compensation, commercial auto, professional liability, cyber, and trucking. Led by owner Kyle Kriegel, the agency emphasizes clear, personalized guidance — "Clear & Simple Insurance" — with free no-obligation policy reviews, online comparative quotes, and 24/7 claims support through a modern client portal.

AutoHomeownersRentersLife+6 more
Waco, TX· 172.4 mi
Carriers: American Economy Insurance Company, GEICO County Mutual Insurance Company +21-2 agents
P Listed
Patterson Insurance Agency
4.8 · <100 reviews on Google

Patterson Insurance is a Texas and Louisiana based agency that helps customers find the best coverage by shopping top national carriers. They emphasize fast, simple service with personal agents and prioritize customer support.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersRenters+1 more
Cedar Creek, TX· 3.9 mi
Carriers: ACUITY, A MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY, ALLIED PROPERTY AND CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY +2843-5 agents
View profile
R Listed
Red Oak Insurance Agency
4.8 · <100 reviews on Google45 yrs in business

Red Oak Insurance is a full‑service multiline agency in Carthage, Texas offering homeowners, auto, boat, motorcycle, life, and commercial general liability coverage. Founded in 1981, the agency emphasizes personalized service and competitive pricing for individuals and businesses in East Texas.

AutoBoatCommercial GLHomeowners+3 more
Red Oak, TX· 5.1 mi
Carriers: Economy Fire & Casualty Company, Economy Preferred Insurance Company +61-2 agents
View profile
M Listed
Matt Pittman - Red Oak Insurance Agency
45 yrs in business

Red Oak Insurance is a full‑service multiline agency in Carthage, Texas offering competitive insurance policies for homes, automobiles, boats, motorcycles, mobile homes, travel trailers, businesses and life. Founded in 1981, the agency emphasizes personalized service and customized coverage options.

AutoBoatCommercial GLHomeowners+3 more
Red Oak, TX· 5.1 mi
1-2 agents
View profile
R Listed
RICHARD H. THOMAS, INC.

Licensed insurance agency in Carthage, TX; represents 117 carriers.

AutoHomeownersRentersCommercial GL+1 more
Carthage, TX· 0.0 mi
Carriers: ACUITY, A MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY, AIG Assurance Company +1151-2 agents
View profile
F Listed
FOSSIER EDGE INSURANCE & ASSOCIATES, LLC

Licensed insurance agency in Carthage, TX; represents 52 carriers.

AutoHomeownersRentersCommercial GL+1 more
Carthage, TX· 0.0 mi
Carriers: Ace American Insurance Company, AmGUARD Insurance Company +501-2 agents
View profile
P Listed
PARKER BROWN INSURANCE GROUP LLC

Licensed insurance agency in Carthage, TX. Contact directly for available products and carriers.

AutoHomeownersRentersCommercial GL+1 more
Carthage, TX· 0.0 mi
1-2 agents
View profile
I Listed
INSURANCE SERVICES OF AMERICA LLC

Licensed insurance agency in De Berry, TX; represents 9 carriers.

AutoHomeownersRentersCommercial GL+1 more
De Berry, TX· 12.6 mi
Carriers: AETNA HEALTH AND LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY, Aetna Better Health of Texas Inc. +71-2 agents
View profile
R Listed
RILEY INSURANCE SOLUTIONS LLC

Licensed insurance agency in Beckville, TX; represents 10 carriers.

AutoHomeownersRentersCommercial GL+1 more
Beckville, TX· 13.1 mi
Carriers: Care Improvement Plus South Central Insurance Company, Cariten Health Plan Inc. +81-2 agents
View profile

Frequently asked questions

How much renters insurance do I need?

Inventory your belongings (electronics, furniture, clothing, etc.) and choose a personal property limit that covers replacement. Most renters need $20,000-$50,000 in personal property plus $100,000 in liability.

Does my landlord's insurance cover my stuff?

No. Your landlord's policy covers the building structure, not your belongings. If a fire, theft, or water damage destroys your possessions, you'll need your own renters policy to be reimbursed.

Will renters insurance cover my roommate?

Generally no -- each tenant should have their own policy. Some carriers allow roommates on a single policy if both are named, but it's cleaner (and usually similar cost) to have separate policies.