Skip to content

Renters Insurance in Carrollton, TX

Renters insurance covers your belongings inside a rented unit and provides liability protection if a guest is injured. Many Texas landlords require it. Average annual cost is well under $200, making it one of the highest-value insurance products available.

24 renters insurance agencies in Carrollton

Within 15 miles of Carrollton, TX. Click any agency to view profile, contact info, and request a quote.

LFeatured partner
LIBERTAS INSURANCEPaid placement

Libertas Insurance (Libertas Group, LLC) is an independent insurance agency headquartered in Waco, Texas, with a second office in Austin, serving individuals, families, and businesses across the state. As an independent agency, Libertas isn't tied to a single carrier — it compares multiple companies to fit each client's needs across personal lines (auto, home, life, umbrella, flood, boat, and motorcycle) and a full range of commercial coverage, including general liability, commercial property, workers' compensation, commercial auto, professional liability, cyber, and trucking. Led by owner Kyle Kriegel, the agency emphasizes clear, personalized guidance — "Clear & Simple Insurance" — with free no-obligation policy reviews, online comparative quotes, and 24/7 claims support through a modern client portal.

AutoHomeownersRentersLife+6 more
Waco, TX· 98.4 mi
Carriers: American Economy Insurance Company, GEICO County Mutual Insurance Company +210+ agents
L Listed
Lopez Auto Insurance
4.9 · 279 reviews on Google15 yrs in business

Lopez Auto Insurance is a Texas‑based agency offering a range of coverage options including auto, homeowners, mobile home, motorcycle and boat insurance. Since 2011 they focus on quick quotes, personalized service and community‑focused support to help customers protect what matters most.

AutoBoatCommercial GLHomeowners+3 more
Carrollton, TX· 0.8 mi
6+ agents
View profile
S Listed
Sanchez Insurance & More
4.0 · 26 reviews on Google29 yrs in business

Sanchez Insurance is an agency offering auto, home, business, life, motorcycle and RV coverage. Their dedicated staff shops multiple carriers to find affordable policies and has served hundreds of customers for over a decade.

AutoCommercial GLCommercial PropertyHomeowners+4 moreSpanish
Carrollton, TX· 0.7 mi
Carriers: Falcon Insurance Company, PROGRESSIVE COUNTY MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY +110+ agents
View profile
E Listed
Ezzy Insurance (formerly Advanced Insurance Group)
4.9 · 537 reviews on Google18 yrs in business

Ezzy Insurance, originally founded as Advance Insurance Group in 2008, provides a range of insurance products at competitive prices. The agency emphasizes personal service and bilingual support to help customers with their insurance needs.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersMotorcycle+2 moreSpanish
Dallas, TX· 6.1 mi
Carriers: Berkshire Hathaway Homestate Insurance Company, GEICO County Mutual Insurance Company +320+ agents
View profile
B Listed
Brightway Insurance, The Janie Alonzo Agency
4.9 · 192 reviews on Google

Brightway Insurance offers an independent‑agent approach, promising insurance on your terms with personalized quotes and a focus on community service.

AutoBoatCommercial GLFlood+5 more
Carrollton, TX· 3.6 mi
20+ agents
View profile
L Listed
La Familia Auto Insurance
4.7 · 814 reviews on Google15 yrs in business

La Familia Insurance aims to protect families with affordable, reliable coverage, emphasizing that everyone deserves access regardless of background. Their mission is to eliminate the fear of loss by offering auto, home, renters, and business insurance with a bilingual, community‑focused approach.

AutoCommercial GLCommercial PropertyHomeowners+2 moreSpanish
Carrollton, TX· 0.6 mi
Carriers: Bravo General (in-house MGA), GAINSCO +56+ agents
View profile
A Listed
A-Affordable has partnered with Freeway Insurance
4.0 · 7 reviews on Google39 yrs in business

Freeway Insurance is a nationwide agency that lets customers compare quotes from over 200 carrier partners for auto, homeowners, renters and motorcycle coverage. They emphasize fast online quoting, bilingual agents, and a large network of local offices to provide personalized service across all 50 states.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersMotorcycle+2 moreSpanish
Carrollton, TX· 1.0 mi
Carriers: Confie (parent MGA), Progressive County Mutual +410+ agents
View profile
A Listed
ABEST BONDS & INSURANCE AGENCY, LLC
4.8 · 68 reviews on Google

Licensed insurance agency in Carrollton, TX; represents 11 carriers.

AutoHomeownersRentersCommercial GL+1 more
Carrollton, TX· 0.8 mi
Carriers: American Surety Company, Contractors Bonding and Insurance Company +920+ agents
View profile
L Listed
Logan Harvey: Allstate Insurance
4.9 · 103 reviews on Google10 yrs in business

Harvey Insurance is a trusted local agency serving families and businesses across Texas, offering personal and business insurance lines backed by top carriers. They emphasize personalized service, local expertise, and 24/7 claims support.

AutoHomeownersRentersUmbrella+5 more
Addison, TX· 4.1 mi
6+ agents
View profile
M Listed
Mike Leonard Insurance Agency
4.4 · 30 reviews on Google

Mike Leonard Insurance Agency LLC provides personal auto and homeowners insurance, highlighting simple online quotes and comprehensive coverage to give customers peace of mind.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersRenters+1 more
Carrollton, TX· 3.5 mi
Carriers: Aegis Security Insurance Company, American Economy Insurance Company +5020+ agents
View profile
F Listed
Fiesta Auto Insurance & Tax Service
4.9 · 147 reviews on Google

Fiesta Auto Insurance offers auto, home, business, rental property, boat, and motorcycle insurance along with personal and business tax services, targeting Latino customers in Texas.

AutoBoatCommercial GLHomeowners+3 moreSpanish
Carrollton, TX· 0.7 mi
Carriers: Progressive County Mutual, Pronto Insurance (affiliate) +46+ agents
View profile
A Listed
America's Best Auto Insurance
4.9 · 1,171 reviews on Google

Licensed insurance agency in Carrollton, TX; represents 8 carriers.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersRenters+1 moreSpanish
Carrollton, TX· 0.8 mi
Carriers: Progressive County Mutual, GAINSCO +66+ agents
View profile
F Listed
Farmers Insurance - Kristin Gaca
4.8 · 32 reviews on Google

Kristin Gaca is a Farmers Insurance agent located in Lewisville, Texas. The page offers options to get quotes for auto, home, renters, and life insurance.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersLife+2 more
Lewisville, TX· 6.0 mi
Carriers: Homesite Insurance Company, Infinity County Mutual Insurance Company +220+ agents
View profile
C Listed
CINCO Auto Insurance
4.9 · 816 reviews on Google

Cinco Auto Insurance provides customizable auto, homeowners, renters, and business insurance solutions across Texas, serving over 900 cities with bilingual agents and a focus on competitive rates and quick coverage.

AutoCommercial GLCommercial PropertyHomeowners+2 moreSpanish
Dallas, TX· 7.3 mi
10+ agents
View profile
L Listed
Lopez Auto Insurance
4.9 · 600 reviews on Google15 yrs in business

Lopez Auto Insurance, based in Dallas, TX, has been serving customers since 2011 offering a range of insurance options including auto, homeowners, mobile home, motorcycle, boat, and commercial auto coverage. The agency emphasizes quick quotes, friendly staff, and affordable plans tailored to individual needs.

AutoBoatCommercial GLHomeowners+3 more
Dallas, TX· 7.0 mi
6+ agents
View profile
R Listed
REALM HEALTH INSURANCE AGENCY LLC
4.7 · 146 reviews on Google

Licensed insurance agency in Dallas, TX; represents 4 carriers.

AutoHomeownersRentersCommercial GL+1 more
Dallas, TX· 3.7 mi
Carriers: 5 Star Life Insurance Company, AMALGAMATED LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY +220+ agents
View profile
G Listed
GLOBAL SOLUTIONS AGENCY LLC
4.8 · 47 reviews on Google

Licensed insurance agency in Dallas, TX; represents 6 carriers.

AutoHomeownersRentersCommercial GL+1 more
Dallas, TX· 3.6 mi
Carriers: Alinsco Insurance Company, Fidelity & Guaranty Life Insurance Company +420+ agents
View profile
L Listed
Leo's Auto Insurance
4.9 · 247 reviews on Google10 yrs in business

Leo’s Auto Insurance provides reliable and affordable coverage across 14+ locations, partnering with 35+ top carriers to offer 140+ plans. The agency focuses on fast quotes and personalized solutions for drivers and homeowners.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersMotorcycle+2 moreSpanish
Dallas, TX· 5.4 mi
6+ agents
View profile
R Listed
Rising Star Insurance Group
4.8 · 35 reviews on Google40 yrs in business

Rising Star Insurance Group specializes in safeguarding businesses, homes, and futures, offering personalized insurance solutions with over 40 years of trusted experience and a focus on integrity, expertise, and exceptional service.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersRenters+1 more
Richardson, TX· 9.3 mi
Carriers: AMERICAN CASUALTY COMPANY OF READING, PENNSYLVANIA, Ace American Insurance Company +4420+ agents
View profile
F Listed
Freeway Insurance
4.7 · 194 reviews on Google

Freeway is a nationwide insurance agency that offers a variety of products including auto, homeowners, renters, life, motorcycle and boat coverage. The site provides options to get online quotes or call for assistance, and mentions support across all 50 U.S. states.

AutoBoatCommercial GLHomeowners+4 moreSpanish
Carrollton, TX· 0.7 mi
Carriers: Confie (parent MGA), Progressive County Mutual +43-5 agents
View profile
S Listed
Superior Insurance Services
4.8 · 1 reviews on Google

Superior Agency is an insurance agency focused on delivering personalized service with an emphasis on care, trust, and expertise. They aim to treat clients like family and provide comprehensive coverage solutions.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersRenters+1 more
Carrollton, TX· 2.6 mi
10+ agents
View profile
C Listed
COWBOY INSURANCE AGENCY
4.8 · 437 reviews on Google

Cowboy Insurance provides online insurance quotes for auto, homeowners, and commercial coverage, emphasizing savings for customers. The agency highlights its agents’ ability to find the right policy at a fair price.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersRenters+1 moreSpanish
Dallas, TX· 7.5 mi
10+ agents
View profile
T Listed
THE VALE GROUP LLC
4.8 · 20 reviews on Google

Licensed insurance agency in Dallas, TX; represents 38 carriers.

AutoHomeownersRentersCommercial GL+1 more
Dallas, TX· 3.8 mi
Carriers: Aetna Health Inc., Alinsco Insurance Company +3620+ agents
View profile
R Listed
RC Insurance Agency LLC
4.8 · 6 reviews on Google

Licensed insurance agency in Carrollton, TX. Contact directly for available products and carriers.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersRenters+1 more
Carrollton, TX· 0.8 mi
10+ agents
View profile

Frequently asked questions

How much renters insurance do I need?

Inventory your belongings (electronics, furniture, clothing, etc.) and choose a personal property limit that covers replacement. Most renters need $20,000-$50,000 in personal property plus $100,000 in liability.

Does my landlord's insurance cover my stuff?

No. Your landlord's policy covers the building structure, not your belongings. If a fire, theft, or water damage destroys your possessions, you'll need your own renters policy to be reimbursed.

Will renters insurance cover my roommate?

Generally no -- each tenant should have their own policy. Some carriers allow roommates on a single policy if both are named, but it's cleaner (and usually similar cost) to have separate policies.

Renters insurance in other Texas cities

Other insurance types in Carrollton