Skip to content

Renters Insurance in The Colony, TX

Renters insurance covers your belongings inside a rented unit and provides liability protection if a guest is injured. Many Texas landlords require it. Average annual cost is well under $200, making it one of the highest-value insurance products available.

24 renters insurance agencies in The Colony

Within 15 miles of The Colony, TX. Click any agency to view profile, contact info, and request a quote.

LFeatured partner
LIBERTAS INSURANCEPaid placement

Libertas Insurance (Libertas Group, LLC) is an independent insurance agency headquartered in Waco, Texas, with a second office in Austin, serving individuals, families, and businesses across the state. As an independent agency, Libertas isn't tied to a single carrier — it compares multiple companies to fit each client's needs across personal lines (auto, home, life, umbrella, flood, boat, and motorcycle) and a full range of commercial coverage, including general liability, commercial property, workers' compensation, commercial auto, professional liability, cyber, and trucking. Led by owner Kyle Kriegel, the agency emphasizes clear, personalized guidance — "Clear & Simple Insurance" — with free no-obligation policy reviews, online comparative quotes, and 24/7 claims support through a modern client portal.

AutoHomeownersRentersLife+6 more
Waco, TX· 106.1 mi
Carriers: American Economy Insurance Company, GEICO County Mutual Insurance Company +21-2 agents
H Listed
Hotchkiss Insurance
3.9 · <100 reviews on Google51 yrs in business

Hotchkiss Insurance has been protecting businesses, individuals and families since 1975, offering personalized insurance plans such as commercial property and casualty, employee benefits, personal and renters insurance, and surety bonds. Their mission is to help people and businesses thrive by safeguarding what matters most.

AutoCommercial GLCommercial PropertyHomeowners+2 more
Carrollton, TX· 5.2 mi
Carriers: 5 Star Life Insurance Company, ACUITY, A MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY +38010+ agents
View profile
B Listed
Brent Holtz - State Farm Insurance Agent
4.9 · 500+ reviews on Google11 yrs in business

Brent Holtz is a State Farm insurance agent serving The Colony, TX and surrounding North Texas communities, offering auto, homeowners, renters, and life insurance. The office emphasizes bilingual service (English and Spanish) and active community involvement.

AutoBoatCommercial GLHomeowners+4 moreSpanish
The Colony, TX· 1.0 mi
Carriers: State Farm
View profile
R Listed
Robyn Holtz - State Farm Insurance Agent
4.9 · 500+ reviews on Google17 yrs in business

Robyn Holtz State Farm Insurance Office serves Texas, Oklahoma, Arkansas, and Louisiana offering auto, homeowners, renters, life, and small business coverage. The agency emphasizes personalized service, community involvement, and bilingual support for English and Spanish speakers.

AutoBoatCommercial GLHomeowners+4 moreSpanish
The Colony, TX· 1.0 mi
Carriers: State Farm
View profile
I Listed
Ideal Insurance Agency
4.8 · <100 reviews on Google6 yrs in business

Ideal Insurance helps families find the right health, auto, and life insurance plans, emphasizing budget‑friendly options and personalized service.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersLife+2 moreSpanish
The Colony, TX· 1.7 mi
License on file (TDI)
View profile
R Listed
Royalty Insurance
4.9 · 1,000+ reviews on Google

Royalty Insurance is a Texas‑based insurance agency offering affordable rates and highly rated customer service. It provides auto, homeowners, life, and business insurance coverage to protect families and companies. The agency highlights its tailored policies and commitment to client satisfaction.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersLife+2 more
Carrollton, TX· 1.4 mi
Carriers: ALLSTATE FIRE AND CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY, ALLSTATE INDEMNITY COMPANY +971-2 agents
View profile
K Listed
Kurt Grothe - State Farm Insurance Agent
4.9 · 500+ reviews on Google

Kurt Grothe is a State Farm insurance agent in The Colony, TX, serving the DFW area. He combines his background as a pastor and missionary with a focus on personalized auto, homeowners, life, motorcycle and boat insurance. The agency emphasizes community service, 24‑hour support, and multilingual assistance.

AutoBoatCommercial GLHomeowners+4 moreSpanish
The Colony, TX· 1.0 mi
Carriers: STATE FARM GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY, State Farm County Mutual Insurance Company of Texas +41-2 agents
View profile
M Listed
Matt Bischof - GEICO Insurance Agent
4.7 · 500+ reviews on Google85 yrs in business

GEICO Insurance Agency serves the Dallas‑Fort Worth area offering a variety of insurance products such as auto, homeowners, renters, motorcycle, boat, life, umbrella, flood and earthquake coverage. The agency partners with multiple carriers and provides online tools for quotes, policy management and claims.

AutoBoatCommercial GLEarthquake+6 moreSpanish
The Colony, TX· 1.1 mi
Carriers: Agricultural Workers Mutual Auto Insurance Company, American Bankers Insurance Company of Florida +301-2 agents
View profile
J Listed
Justin Young at Comparion Insurance Agency
4.9 · 100+ reviews on Google4 yrs in business

Comparion Insurance Agency, founded in 2022, operates as an independent insurance comparison service backed by Liberty Mutual Group. It partners with over 50 carriers to offer a wide range of products such as auto, home, life, renters, and umbrella coverage, leveraging a national network of agents to deliver personalized service.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersLife+2 more
The Colony, TX· 4.9 mi
Carriers: Progressive, Allstate +4
View profile
M Listed
Mike Bergman - State Farm Insurance Agent
4.9 · 100+ reviews on Google33 yrs in business

Mike Bergman is a State Farm insurance agent serving Texas and Oklahoma since 2007, offering auto, homeowners, renters, life, motorcycle and boat insurance along with other services. His team provides multilingual support in English, Spanish, Cantonese and Mandarin from their Frisco office.

AutoBoatCommercial GLHomeowners+4 moreSpanish, Cantonese
Frisco, TX· 4.4 mi
Carriers: State Farm3-5 agents
View profile
K Listed
Kyle Aubry - State Farm Insurance Agent
4.9 · 100+ reviews on Google17 yrs in business

Agent Kyle Aubry has been serving State Farm customers since 2009 from the Carrollton, Texas office. The agency offers a range of personal insurance products including auto, homeowners, renters, life, motorcycle and boat coverage, as well as business insurance. They provide 24/7 quotes, claim assistance and a free notary public service.

AutoBoatCommercial GLHomeowners+4 more
Carrollton, TX· 5.3 mi
Carriers: State Farm
View profile
N Listed
Nick Fincham - State Farm Insurance Agent
4.9 · 100+ reviews on Google9 yrs in business

Nick Fincham is a State Farm insurance agent in Carrollton, Texas, serving the community since 2017. The agency offers a range of personal and commercial insurance products, including auto, homeowners, renters, life, motorcycle, and boat coverage, and serves English and Spanish speaking clients.

AutoBoatCommercial GLCommercial Property+5 moreSpanish
Carrollton, TX· 3.2 mi
Carriers: State Farm1-2 agents
View profile
L Listed
Lewis Jue - State Farm Insurance Agent
4.5 · <100 reviews on Google38 yrs in business

Lewis Jue, a native of Houston, Texas, became a State Farm Insurance Agent in 1988 after a career in engineering and the U.S. Army. He and his wife focus on providing high‑quality personal and business insurance products with integrity and honesty. The agency serves the Dallas‑area community with a personal, service‑first approach.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersLife+2 more
The Colony, TX· 2.0 mi
Carriers: State Farm
View profile
F Listed
Farmers Insurance - Morgan Sonnier
4.8 · <100 reviews on Google

Morgan Sonnier is a Farmers Insurance agent serving The Colony, Texas. The agency offers a range of insurance options including auto, home, renters, and life coverage.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersLife+2 more
The Colony, TX· 1.5 mi
Carriers: Farmers1-2 agents
View profile
R Listed
Ryan Dunn - State Farm Insurance Agent
4.9 · 100+ reviews on Google4 yrs in business

Ryan Dunn State Farm Agency serves the Dallas‑Fort Worth Metroplex offering a full range of State Farm insurance products. The agency emphasizes personalized, virtual and in‑person service and has been operating since January 2022.

AutoBoatCommercial GLHomeowners+4 moreSpanish
Little Elm, TX· 5.8 mi
Carriers: State Farm
View profile
M Listed
Marc Matney - State Farm Insurance Agent
4.8 · <100 reviews on Google

Marc Matney is a State Farm insurance agent in Lewisville, TX, offering personal insurance services such as auto, homeowners, life, renters, and business coverage. He serves the Lewisville, Denton, and Collin County communities and provides support in both English and Spanish.

AutoBoatCommercial GLHomeowners+4 moreSpanish
The Colony, TX· 1.3 mi
Carriers: State Farm1-2 agents
View profile
D Listed
Dean Insurance Group
4.9 · 100+ reviews on Google

Dean Insurance Group is an independent agency that promises to find the best price for coverage, offering quotes from multiple top insurers and guiding clients through the process.

AutoBoatCommercial GLHomeowners+4 more
Plano, TX· 5.4 mi
Carriers: Kemper, Safeco +6
View profile
J Listed
J J Castilleja - State Farm Insurance Agent
4.9 · 100+ reviews on Google

J J Castilleja is a State Farm insurance agent in Frisco, Texas, offering auto, homeowners, renters, life, motorcycle and boat insurance, along with business and personal coverage. He and his multilingual team serve the community with personalized quotes and financial services.

AutoBoatCommercial GLHomeowners+4 moreSpanish, Hindi
Frisco, TX· 4.9 mi
Carriers: State Farm3-5 agents
View profile
C Listed
Chris Hatfield: Allstate Insurance
4.6 · 100+ reviews on Google10 yrs in business

Chris Hatfield is an Allstate insurance agent serving The Colony, TX and surrounding areas. He offers a range of personal insurance products including auto, homeowners, renters, motorcycle, boat and life coverage, and serves English‑ and Spanish‑speaking customers. The agency holds a 4.5‑star rating based on 976 client reviews.

AutoBoatCommercial GLHomeowners+4 moreSpanish
The Colony, TX· 2.9 mi
Carriers: ALLSTATE FIRE AND CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY, ALLSTATE INDEMNITY COMPANY +191-2 agents
View profile
J Listed
Jeff Van Matre Insurance Agency
4.9 · 100+ reviews on Google

Jeff Van Matre Insurance Agency offers protection to individuals and businesses in Carrollton, TX, and the greater Dallas‑Fort Worth area. As an independent agency they focus on client needs rather than individual sales, providing personalized advice and comprehensive coverage solutions.

AutoHomeownersRentersUmbrella+4 more
Carrollton, TX· 3.7 mi
Carriers: AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY OF HARTFORD, CONNECTICUT, THE, American Economy Insurance Company +751-2 agents
View profile
K Listed
Krystal Smith - State Farm Insurance Agent
4.9 · 100+ reviews on Google19 yrs in business

Krystal Smith is a State Farm agent in Carrollton, TX serving the DFW area since 2007, offering auto, homeowners, renters, life, business and financial services.

AutoBoatCommercial GLHomeowners+4 moreSpanish
Carrollton, TX· 4.4 mi
Carriers: State Farm1-2 agents
View profile
T Listed
Trotter Insurance Group
4.8 · <100 reviews on Google

Trotter Insurance Group, LLC is a Dallas‑area agency offering a range of personal and commercial insurance solutions, highlighted by multiple “Best Insurance Agents” awards from D Magazine. They emphasize personalized service, claiming to know their clients and tailor policies to fit individual needs.

AutoBoatCommercial GLCommercial Property+5 more
Carrollton, TX· 4.4 mi
Carriers: ASI Lloyds, AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY OF HARTFORD, CONNECTICUT, THE +36
View profile
R Listed
Roger Welch Agency, LLC
4.8 · <100 reviews on Google

Roger Welch Agency LLC is an independent insurance agency located in Frisco, Texas, offering personal insurance solutions. They work with multiple carriers to provide personalized coverage options for families.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersLife+3 more
Frisco, TX· 6.0 mi
Carriers: Aegis Security Insurance Company, American General Life Insurance Company +9
View profile
D Listed
David Daniel - State Farm Insurance Agent
4.8 · 100+ reviews on Google43 yrs in business

David Daniel is a second‑generation State Farm agent in Carrollton, Texas, operating since 1983 and recognized with multiple Texas Monthly Magazine awards. The agency offers auto, homeowners, condo, renters, life, health and business insurance and assists clients relocating to the Dallas area.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersLife+2 moreSpanish
Carrollton, TX· 3.8 mi
Carriers: State Farm1-2 agents
View profile

Frequently asked questions

How much renters insurance do I need?

Inventory your belongings (electronics, furniture, clothing, etc.) and choose a personal property limit that covers replacement. Most renters need $20,000-$50,000 in personal property plus $100,000 in liability.

Does my landlord's insurance cover my stuff?

No. Your landlord's policy covers the building structure, not your belongings. If a fire, theft, or water damage destroys your possessions, you'll need your own renters policy to be reimbursed.

Will renters insurance cover my roommate?

Generally no -- each tenant should have their own policy. Some carriers allow roommates on a single policy if both are named, but it's cleaner (and usually similar cost) to have separate policies.

Renters insurance in other Texas cities

Other insurance types in The Colony