Skip to content

Renters Insurance in Schertz, TX

Renters insurance covers your belongings inside a rented unit and provides liability protection if a guest is injured. Many Texas landlords require it. Average annual cost is well under $200, making it one of the highest-value insurance products available.

24 renters insurance agencies in Schertz

Within 15 miles of Schertz, TX. Click any agency to view profile, contact info, and request a quote.

RA

R. Tackett Insurance Agency

Cibolo, TX· 2.5 mi
Agency
Popular
10+ agents10yr

R. Tackett Insurance Agency LLC is an independent insurance agency serving Central Texas, offering auto, home, life, commercial, and farm & ranch insurance. Founded in 2016, they focus on personalized service and local roots.

AutoCommercial GLFarmHomeowners+3 more
Carriers: ASI Lloyds, Ace American Insurance Company, Ace Fire Underwriters Insurance Company +87
View Agency
T#

Texas Tag & Title #11

Schertz, TX· 3.5 mi
Agency
Very Popular
20+ agents14yr

Texas Tag and Title is a woman‑owned, family‑operated agency offering vehicle registration, title transfers, and related services across all 254 Texas counties. They provide online, drive‑thru, and virtual title clerk appointments for quick, convenient processing.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersMotorcycle+2 more
View Agency
SC

Speedy Cash

Converse, TX· 4.9 mi
Agency
Very Popular
10+ agents29yr

Speedy Cash is a loan company offering payday, installment, title loans and other credit products since 1997, serving over 10 million customers across the United States.

Spanish
AutoCommercial GLHomeownersRenters+1 more
Carriers: ACCC Insurance Company, Accident Insurance Company, Inc., Affirmative Insurance Company +40
View Agency
FC

First Command

Universal City, TX· 2.8 mi
Agency
10+ agents

Coaching those who serve in their pursuit of financial security.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersRenters+1 more
View Agency
FI

Farmers Insurance - Taylor Agency

Converse, TX· 1.8 mi
Agency
Popular
20+ agents

Licensed insurance agency in Converse, TX; represents 1 carrier.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersLife+2 more
Carriers: Farmers
View Agency
IS

Independence Title Schertz

Cibolo, TX· 3.5 mi
Agency
20+ agents

Independence Title Schertz Office provides title and escrow services to the Schertz, TX community. The office is staffed by a branch manager and several escrow officers who can be reached by phone or email.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersRenters+1 more
View Agency
PS

Prestige Claims Service

Cibolo, TX· 1.6 mi
Agency
New on InsurConnect
10+ agents9yr

Prestige Claims Service provides comprehensive claims handling for commercial, residential, catastrophe, daily, appraisal, and umpire services, emphasizing quality, integrity, and excellence.

AutoCommercial GLCommercial PropertyHomeowners+2 more
View Agency
EL

Elite Tax LLC®️

Converse, TX· 5.1 mi
Agency
Very Popular
10+ agents

Elite Tax Services, LLC provides tax preparation, planning, and forensic investigation services, emphasizing responsive, personalized client care throughout the San Antonio area and surrounding communities.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersRenters+1 more
View Agency
HA

Hickman Insurance Agency

Schertz, TX· 2.9 mi
Agency
Popular
10+ agents

Licensed insurance agency in Schertz, TX; represents 21 carriers.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersLife+2 more
Carriers: Consumers County Mutual Insurance Company, Foremost County Mutual Insurance Company, Foremost Insurance Company Grand Rapids, Michigan +18
View Agency
MO

Medicare San Antonio Insurance Options

Cibolo, TX· 2.9 mi
Agency
New on InsurConnect
20+ agents

Melody Nasiatka is a licensed Medicare broker in San Antonio helping seniors navigate Medicare Advantage and other Medicare options. She offers one‑on‑one consultations, side‑by‑side plan comparisons, and educational presentations.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersRenters+1 more
View Agency
IE

InSight EyeCare

Cibolo, TX· 2.5 mi
Agency
10+ agents

Insight Eyecare is an optometry practice in Cibolo, Texas offering comprehensive eye exams, contact lenses, glasses, and specialty services such as Ortho‑K. The clinic emphasizes personalized patient care, a comfortable environment, and same‑day glasses. They accept insurance and offer financing options.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersRenters+1 more
View Agency
TL

Trucksure Insurance Agency LLC

Cibolo, TX· 2.4 mi
Agency
New on InsurConnect
6+ agents15yr

TruckSure Insurance provides reliable, affordable truck insurance tailored for owner‑operators and fleets across the United States. Their coverage protects vehicles, cargo, and business liability, offering physical damage, commercial auto liability, cargo, and general liability options. The agency emphasizes fast claims processing and dedicated roadside support.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersRenters+1 more
Carriers: Berkshire Hathaway Homestate Insurance Company, Redwood Fire and Casualty Insurance Company
View Agency
WA

Will Peterson Insurance Agency

Cibolo, TX· 1.4 mi
Agency
No reviews yet
10+ agents

Allstate agents in Texas provide auto, homeowners, and life insurance coverage across the state.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersLife+2 more
Carriers: Allstate
View Agency
TS

Tisdale Auto Title Services

Universal City, TX· 2.7 mi
Agency
10+ agents

San Antonio Auto Title provides fast and convenient title transfers, registrations, and inspections across seven locations in San Antonio. They partner with a local dealership to streamline vehicle paperwork for new residents and buyers.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersRenters+1 more
View Agency
BI

Bienvenido Insurance

San Antonio, TX· 11.9 mi
Agency
Very Popular
10+ agents12yr

Bienvenido Insurance is a locally owned agency that helps customers secure auto, home, renters, life, motorcycle and commercial insurance policies. Their staff emphasizes personalized service, fast response, and finding the best rates from a wide range of carriers. They have been serving the community for over a decade.

Spanish
AutoCommercial GLHomeownersLife+3 more
Carriers: ACCC Insurance Company, Alinsco Insurance Company, Allied Trust Insurance Company +18
View Agency
TT

The Insurance Agency TX

Converse, TX· 7.9 mi
Agency
New on InsurConnect
10+ agents

The Insurance Guys is an independent insurance agency. We help individuals and businesses find insurance coverage tailored to their specific needs. We draw from a vast pool of experience with personal insurance and commercial insurance policies from a range of respected insurance providers.

Spanish
AutoCommercial GLCommercial PropertyHomeowners+3 more
Carriers: Aetna Better Health of Texas Inc., Aetna Health Inc., Care Improvement Plus South Central Insurance Company +8
View Agency
JL

Joseph Reyes Consulting LLC

Cibolo, TX· 0.5 mi
Agency
New on InsurConnect
20+ agents

Licensed insurance agency in Cibolo, TX. Contact directly for available products and carriers.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersRenters+1 more
View Agency
BH

Bill Hicks - State Farm Insurance Agent

Converse, TX· 0.4 mi
Agency
Very Popular
1-2 agents31yr

Bill Hicks State Farm Insurance serves Schertz, Texas and surrounding areas, offering auto, home, life, renters, condo, motorcycle, RV, boat and business insurance. With over 31 years of experience as a local State Farm agent, Bill Hicks and his team provide personalized insurance and financial services to individuals and small businesses.

Spanish
AutoBoatCommercial GLHomeowners+4 more
Carriers: State Farm
View Agency
AI

A-MAX Auto Insurance

Converse, TX· 1.5 mi
Agency
6+ agents

A-MAX Insurance is a trusted, community‑focused insurance agency that helps customers compare coverage options from 35+ top‑rated insurance companies offering over 400 plans. It makes it easy to find affordable protection for cars, homes, roadside assistance and more while delivering personalized service you can count on.

Spanish
AutoBoatCommercial GLCommercial Property+3 more
Carriers: Progressive County Mutual, Direct Auto Insurance, Mercury Insurance +4
View Agency
SC

Standard Casualty Company

New Braunfels, TX· 13.1 mi
Agency
Very Popular
10+ agents65yr

Standard Casualty Company specializes in affordable mobile, manufactured, modular, and factory‑built home insurance. Founded in 1961, they provide comprehensive coverage including fire, hail, windstorm, flood, and earthquake. They are part of the Cavco family and focus on protecting families and their homes.

AutoCommercial GLEarthquakeFlood+3 more
Carriers: GEICO Texas County Mutual Insurance Company, Old American County Mutual Fire Insurance Company, Standard Casualty Company
View Agency
BA

Brenda Heulitt Insurance Agency

New Braunfels, TX· 13.2 mi
Agency
Popular
20+ agents13yr

Independent insurance broker helping Texas families and businesses understand their coverage, avoid costly gaps, and stay protected long after the policy is purchased.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersLife+2 more
Carriers: AssuranceAmerica Insurance Company, Economy Fire & Casualty Company, Economy Preferred Insurance Company +5
View Agency
SG

Steven Garza - State Farm Insurance Agent

Cibolo, TX· 1.6 mi
Agency
Very Popular
1-2 agents8yr

Steven Garza Insurance Agency is a State Farm agency in Schertz, Texas serving Schertz, Cibolo, Selma and surrounding areas since 2018. The team offers a range of insurance products and provides service in English and Spanish.

Spanish
AutoBoatCommercial GLHomeowners+4 more
Carriers: MGA Insurance Company, Inc., STATE FARM GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY, State Farm Classic Insurance Company +5
View Agency
FI

Farmers Insurance - Steven Gonzales

Converse, TX· 3.6 mi
Agency
Very Popular
155yr

The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) supports state insurance regulators by setting standards, providing research, analytics, and consumer protection resources. It has been serving the public interest and strengthening insurance markets since 1871.

AutoCommercial GLHomeownersRenters+1 more
View Agency
JF

Jeremy Fuller - State Farm Insurance Agent

Cibolo, TX· 2.3 mi
Agency
Very Popular
1-2 agents22yr

Jeremy Fuller is a State Farm insurance agent with 22 years of experience offering a full range of State Farm approved products including auto, home, renters, small business, disability, pet, and life insurance, serving the San Antonio area and surrounding states.

Spanish
AutoBoatCommercial GLDisability+5 more
Carriers: MGA Insurance Company, Inc., STATE FARM GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY, State Farm Classic Insurance Company +5
View Agency

Frequently asked questions

How much renters insurance do I need?

Inventory your belongings (electronics, furniture, clothing, etc.) and choose a personal property limit that covers replacement. Most renters need $20,000-$50,000 in personal property plus $100,000 in liability.

Does my landlord's insurance cover my stuff?

No. Your landlord's policy covers the building structure, not your belongings. If a fire, theft, or water damage destroys your possessions, you'll need your own renters policy to be reimbursed.

Will renters insurance cover my roommate?

Generally no -- each tenant should have their own policy. Some carriers allow roommates on a single policy if both are named, but it's cleaner (and usually similar cost) to have separate policies.